Week 10 · Balance & Motor Control

Balance & Postural Sway

Turn a smartphone into a balance lab. Quantify how base of support and vision change trunk sway, sway velocity and sway area.

Pre-lab ≈ 25 minIn-lab 90 minReport ≈ 90 minTools: Phyphox app, scale, Excel

Overview

Standing still is not still. Upright posture requires continuous neuromuscular adjustments to keep the center of mass (COM) inside the base of support (BOS). These adjustments are measured as postural sway, which reflects how the nervous system integrates visual, vestibular and somatosensory information. You will record trunk acceleration with a smartphone during three standing conditions and calculate velocity, estimated force and sway area.

Learning objectives

  1. Explain how balance control changes with altered base of support and sensory conditions.
  2. Collect tri-axial accelerometer data with the Phyphox app.
  3. Process raw acceleration with a moving RMS filter; calculate resultant acceleration, velocity and force.
  4. Construct medial–lateral (ML) vs. anterior–posterior (AP) sway plots and calculate sway area.
  5. Critically evaluate smartphone-based balance assessment against force-plate methods.
ComponentWhat you doTime
Pre-labStability, COM/COP, sensory systems, accelerometry; quiz20–30 min
Lab activityThree 30-s balance conditions per student; export and begin processing90 min
Lab reportSmoothing, resultant, velocity, force, stabilograms, sway area, discussion≈ 90 min
Install before labInstall the free Phyphox app (iOS or Android).

Pre-Lab Reading ≈ 15 min

1. Stability, COM and base of support

A body is statically stable when the vertical projection of its COM falls inside its base of support (the area bounded by the contact points with the ground). Stability increases with a larger BOS, a lower COM, a COM projected closer to the center of the BOS, and greater mass. Going from two feet to one shrinks the BOS dramatically — especially in the medial–lateral direction, because one foot is long but narrow.

2. Sensory control of balance

  • Visual — where you are relative to the room; removing it (eyes closed) typically increases sway substantially.
  • Vestibular — inner-ear sense of head acceleration and orientation.
  • Somatosensory — pressure under the feet and proprioception from muscles and joints (ankle especially).

Balance control combines feedforward (anticipatory) and feedback (corrective) mechanisms. Small sways are corrected with an "ankle strategy"; larger perturbations recruit a "hip strategy" or a step.

3. Force plates: the gold standard

Force plates measure ground reaction forces and calculate the center of pressure (COP) — the point of application of the GRF. COP moves constantly around the COM to keep it controlled; sway magnitude, velocity and area of the COP are standard balance measures.

4. What a smartphone measures

A smartphone accelerometer measures linear acceleration of whatever it is attached to. Held against the sternum, it measures trunk sway acceleration, not GRF or COP. Using Newton's second law, acceleration can be converted to an estimated trunk sway force F = m·a_res. This represents internal control demands, not the force under the feet.

RMSᵢ = √(Σ a² / N)Moving RMS over a window of N samples (≈ 0.5 s) — smooths noise
a_res = √(a_x² + a_y² + a_z²)Resultant acceleration
vᵢ = vᵢ₋₁ + aᵢ·ΔtVelocity by cumulative integration (area under a–t)
F = m · a_resEstimated trunk sway force (N)
Sway area = π · SD_ML · SD_APEllipse approximation of sway area

5. Which axis is which?

With the phone held upright (portrait) and flat against the sternum, screen facing outward, Phyphox's axes point: x = medial–lateral (left–right), y = vertical (along the long edge of the phone), z = anterior–posterior (out of the screen). Confirm before you record: lean forward and back — the axis that changes most is AP. Label your columns by anatomy (ML, AP, vertical), not by phone letter.

Drift warningIntegrating acceleration accumulates tiny offsets into large velocity drift. Subtract each axis's mean acceleration (detrend) before integrating, and compare conditions using the same processing.

Interactive: What a stabilogram looks like

Simulated trunk-acceleration sway paths for the three conditions, with sway area calculated using the lab formula.

Before you come to lab

  • Install Phyphox and open the Acceleration (without g) experiment once.
  • Know your dominant leg (the leg you kick a ball with).
  • Wear clothing that allows you to hold the phone flat against your sternum; you will remove shoes.

Pre-Lab Quiz ≈ 10 min

A person is statically stable when:
If the COM's line of gravity leaves the BOS, gravity produces an unbalanced torque and the person must step or fall.
What does a force plate measure that a chest-mounted phone does not?
The phone measures acceleration of the trunk segment, not the external forces under the feet.
Which condition is expected to produce the greatest sway?
Smallest base of support plus loss of visual information.
Why might medial–lateral sway increase more than AP sway in single-leg stance?
Going from two feet to one removes most of the ML width of the base of support while AP length (foot length) is similar.
A 70 kg participant has a resultant trunk acceleration of 0.15 m/s². The estimated trunk sway force is:
F = m·a = 70 × 0.15 = 10.5 N. (686.7 N would be body weight.)
A moving RMS filter mainly acts as a:
Averaging the squared signal over a window attenuates fast changes and keeps the slower sway pattern.
SD_ML = 0.08 m/s² and SD_AP = 0.05 m/s². Sway area (π·SD_ML·SD_AP) is:
π × 0.08 × 0.05 = 0.0126.

Short responses (submit to your LMS)

1. Which sensory system do you think you rely on most for balance, and how could you test that in this lab?

2. Predict how a trained gymnast and an 80-year-old adult would differ from you in the single-leg eyes-closed condition. Why?

Lab Activity 90 min

📍 Set up for your campusCheck how Phyphox labels the axes on one iPhone and one Android before class, and post the result for students.

Group organization

4 teams of 5, two phones per team so two participants can be tested at once. Roles: Participant, Phone operator (starts timed run), Spotter (stands close, never touches unless needed), Condition monitor (checks stance and watches for touch-downs), Recorder.

Equipment per team

  • 2 smartphones with Phyphox
  • Body-mass scale
  • Quiet space with a wall nearby for safety
  • Laptops with Excel
SafetyEyes-closed single-leg stance is a fall risk. The spotter stands within arm's reach for every eyes-closed trial. Perform trials on a firm, flat floor away from furniture.

Timeline

  • 0:00–0:10Briefing; Phyphox set-up demo; axis check (lean forward/back, side to side).
  • 0:10–0:15Measure body mass; identify dominant leg; remove shoes.
  • 0:15–0:55Data collection: every student completes the three conditions (≈ 4 min per participant including rest; two phones in parallel).
  • 0:55–1:05Export data from Phyphox (Excel format) and transfer to laptops.
  • 1:05–1:30Processing workshop: detrend, RMS smoothing and first stabilogram with instructor support.

Phyphox set-up

  1. Open Acceleration (without g) (linear acceleration). If your instructor uses Acceleration with g, you will subtract each axis's mean in Excel.
  2. Tap the ⋮ menu → Timed run: start delay 5.0 s, experiment duration 30.0 s. Do not change the sampling rate.
  3. Hold the phone upright, flat against the sternum, screen facing outward, with both hands crossed over it. Same orientation for every trial — the phone must not move independently of the torso.

Conditions (30 s each, 30–60 s rest between)

  1. Double-leg stance, eyes open — feet together, gaze at a fixed point at eye level.
  2. Single-leg stance on dominant leg, eyes open — lift the other foot to mid-shank height without touching.
  3. Single-leg stance on dominant leg, eyes closed. If the foot touches down, note the time; repeat once if it occurs in the first 10 s.

Export

Tap the export icon → Excel → send via AirDrop, email or cloud. Name files LastName_DLEO.xlsx, _SLEO, _SLEC.

Lab Report ≈ 90 min

Backup data setAbsent, or your trial failed? Use this simulated data set. It has the same columns as the lab data sheet, so every formula below works unchanged. Tell your instructor in your report that you used it. Participant body mass for force: 68 kg. Axes: x = ML, y = vertical, z = AP.
⬇ Double-leg, eyes open · Single-leg, eyes open · Single-leg, eyes closed

Step 1 — Processing (one sheet per condition) ≈ 35 min

Assume Phyphox columns: A = time (s), B = x (ML), C = y (vertical), D = z (AP); sampling ≈ 100 Hz.

New columnFormula (row 2, copy down)Purpose
E: ML detrended=B2-AVERAGE(B$2:B$3001)Removes offset/gravity
F: AP detrended=D2-AVERAGE(D$2:D$3001)
G: Vertical detrended=C2-AVERAGE(C$2:C$3001)
H: ML smoothed (RMS, start row 51)=SQRT(SUMSQ(E2:E51)/50)≈ 0.5 s window
I: AP smoothed (RMS)=SQRT(SUMSQ(F2:F51)/50)
J: Resultant (m/s²)=SQRT(E2^2+F2^2+G2^2)
K: ML velocity (m/s)K2 = 0; K3 = K2+(A3-A2)*E3Cumulative integration
L: AP velocity (m/s)L2 = 0; L3 = L2+(A3-A2)*F3
M: Resultant velocity=SQRT(K2^2+L2^2)
N: Force (N)=$Q$1*J2Q1 = body mass (kg)

Adjust 3001 to your last row. Note that the moving RMS is always positive; for stabilograms you may also plot a signed moving average (=AVERAGE(E2:E51)) to keep direction.

Step 2 — Summary table ≈ 10 min

Table 1 (per condition): SD_ML, SD_AP (STDEV.S of detrended acceleration), sway area = =PI()*SD_ML*SD_AP, mean resultant velocity, mean and peak force, touch-downs. Add team means ± SD in Table 2.

Step 3 — Required graphs ≈ 20 min

  1. Figure 1. Force vs. time for all three conditions on one chart.
  2. Figures 2–4. ML (x-axis) vs. AP (y-axis) sway plots for each condition ("Postural Sway Pattern – [Condition]"). Use identical axis limits on all three so they can be compared visually.
  3. Figure 5. Bar graph of sway area across conditions (team mean ± SD).
  4. Figure 6. Bar graph of mean resultant sway velocity across conditions.

Step 4 — Discussion questions ≈ 25 min

Answer the five required questions. Optional questions earn up to +3 extra-credit points.

  1. Which condition produced the greatest postural sway and why?
  2. How did removing vision affect sway magnitude and velocity?
  3. Why does single-leg stance increase postural control demands? Refer to base of support.
  4. Compare ML vs. AP sway across conditions. Why might ML sway be more sensitive to the change in stance?
  5. Why are trunk sway forces different from ground reaction forces? What assumptions are made when estimating force from acceleration?

Optional questions (extra credit)

  1. How does sway velocity complement sway area when interpreting balance?
  2. How might arm movement or phone placement affect your results?
  3. How would you expect trained athletes or older adults to differ, and what would a clinician use this information for?
  4. What are the key limitations of smartphone-based balance assessment compared with force plates?

Submission checklist

  • Excel workbook: three processed condition sheets, summary tables, Figures 1–6.
  • Document: tables, figures with captions, discussion answers.

Grading rubric (50 pts)

CriterionPtsFull credit looks like
Processing14Correct axis labels, detrending, RMS, integration, force
Tables & graphs14All six figures, consistent axes for stabilograms
Discussion18Sensory and BOS mechanisms, honest limitations
Presentation4Professional and complete

References

  • Winter, D. A. (1995). Human balance and posture control during standing and walking. Gait & Posture, 3(4), 193–214. doi.org/10.1016/0966-6362(96)82849-9
  • Staacks, S., Hütz, S., Heinke, H., & Stampfer, C. (2018). Advanced tools for smartphone-based experiments: phyphox. Physics Education, 53(4), 045009. doi.org/10.1088/1361-6552/aac05e